FEB 27, 2025 | Tulsi Gabbard, now U.S. Director of National Intelligence, has confirmed that U.S. officials and DNI lawyers are now reviewing whether the United Kingdom breached a bilateral treaty known as the CLOUD Act. Under the agreement, the UK is prohibited from demanding access to the data of U.S. citizens or individuals within U.S. borders. 

Stephen Kent, Media Director for the Consumer Choice Center, an international consumer advocacy group based in Washington, D.C., reacted to news of Gabbard’s invoking the CLOUD Act:

“Gabbard is spot on in her defense of American consumers at home and abroad being threatened by the UK’s effort to break Apple’s encryption for users. The nature of consumer encryption tech is that if it’s broken anywhere, it’s broken everywhere. The UK is acting more like China and less like a democratic ally of the US.”

The UK’s Home Office demanded access to encrypted Apple iCloud data under the Investigatory Powers Act (IPA, which would create a “backdoor” for the UK to Apple’s encryption for all its consumers worldwide. As a result, Apple has opted to suspend its Advanced Data Protection encryption feature for UK users. 

“This mode of thinking is why Europe was taken off guard last week by Vice President JD Vance’s speech at the Munich Security Conference. What Gabbard is pointing out in her defense of encryption is that an ally of the United States is trying to violate their citizens’ privacy in a way that compromises consumers in the United States,” Kent continued. 

“The FBI under former Director Christopher Wray used to advocate for the same ‘backdoor’ access to encryption, but they’ve since changed their tune about encryption because of the rising threat of foreign data hacks, which pose huge risks to American consumers and companies.”

Cybersecurity analysts have long warned that any backdoor created for a government could eventually be discovered and misused by cybercriminals and hostile foreign actors. The UK’s push to weaken encryption disregards these risks, potentially exposing sensitive data to hackers and bad actors worldwide.

Kent concluded, “There are few consumer privacy issues as important in the world today as maintaining the integrity of encryption technology and services. The Trump Administration should pull no punches in letting Keir Starmer’s government know that this kind of ‘big brother’ behavior won’t be tolerated and makes our people worse off.” 

FOR MEDIA QUERIES OR INTERVIEWS PLEASE CONTACT:

Stephen Kent

Consumer Choice Center

stephen@consumerchoicecenter.org

###

The Consumer Choice Center is an independent, nonpartisan consumer advocacy group championing the benefits of freedom of choice, innovation, and abundance in everyday life for consumers in over 100 countries. We closely monitor regulatory trends in Washington, Brussels, Ottawa, Brasilia, London, and Geneva. Find out more at www.consumerchoicecenter.org.