As autonomous vehicles (AVs) have become more common across the United States, the predictions about their impact on human drivers have mostly been dire: human rideshare drivers would see paychecks evaporate (so critics have said). The claim has been that AV companies like Waymo would undercut drivers, then Uber and Lyft would squeeze their pay-per-trip, and riders would be left with a choice between a driverless car and nothing.
Two years of data from San Francisco says quite the opposite.
San Francisco is the most established urban market in the world for AVs operating on the same roads as traditional rideshare firms. To date, AV competition has not wrecked driver pay in this large market. Instead, new data from Gridwise Analytics, tracking rideshare earnings from Q2 2024 to Q2 2026, shows the financial squeeze landed entirely on the platforms, not on drivers or riders.
The rideshare platforms took the hit, not drivers
The “take rate” is the share of each fare that Uber and Lyft keep for themselves. In San Francisco, it fell 46.3% over two years. In U.S. cities with no autonomous competition, it rose 6.9% over the same period.
In dollars, the platforms now keep $1.64 per San Francisco trip, down from $3.10, a drop of 47.1%. Nationwide, in cities without AVs, the platforms’ per-trip take climbed 19.2%.
That is what competition looks like in an open market. When a rival shows up with a product people want, the incumbents can’t keep raising their cut. They have to give some of it back or suffer a loss of drivers they need to keep cars available for riders on the app.
David Clement, Policy Director for the Consumer Choice Center, said this about the new study by Gridwise:
“Despite what ridesharing companies might argue, the Gridwise data shows that Waymo expansion is a win-win. Consumers win with more competition and access to new innovative technology, and rideshare drivers win with higher take home pay per ride. Nothing benefits the consumer more than a competitve market with new products. That’s true in the consumer tech sector and it’s true at the intersection of transporation and tech.”
Riders paid nothing extra
The average San Francisco fare didn’t move for the consumer: $16.95, a 0.0% change over two years. Outside AV cities, median customer prices rose 11.7%. San Francisco riders were spared the fare inflation everyone else absorbed. Economics remains undefeated: An alternative on the road works as a price ceiling.
Riders can open a different app if they aren’t happy—they have new choices —so the platforms can’t charge whatever they like.
Drivers are making more money
The money the platforms stopped keeping went to the people behind the wheel. San Francisco drivers’ quarterly earnings rose 16.0% over the two years, and the city posted the highest hourly gross pay of the five AV markets in the report, at $24.60.
Gridwise found trips per hour in AV cities fell 5.3%, about twice the national drop. Less busy time means lower hourly pay, so drivers log off or switch apps to work for a different provider. To keep enough cars available for fast pickups, the platforms have to pay drivers more from their own share to retain them. Drivers have leverage—because many consumers will always prefer a human operator behind the wheel, even as the popularity of AVs increases.
Each consumer is different, so choice remains the most powerful factor in the market.
What this means for policy
Cities and states are still debating whether to slow, cap, or ban autonomous vehicles, often in the name of protecting drivers. The San Francisco numbers point the other way. Riders kept their prices, drivers took home more, and the only party that lost ground was the one that had been raising its cut everywhere else.
In the Consumer Choice Center’s Autonomous Vehicle policy report, you can get an overview of the policies that most benefit consumers while maintaining a fair market for drivers and riders.
Lawmakers who want to protect consumers and workers should let AVs compete, not legislate them off the road. Competition did more for San Francisco drivers in two years than any pay mandate has. Other cities deserve the same chance.